I know Clint has already done a Spider-Man review, but I thought I would chip in with one as well, especially since I have a varied opinion on the film. As someone who has read hundreds of Spidey stories through the years and has too much knowledge of this character, it was obviously with great expectation (and trepidation) that I went to see this film. It is obviously hard to tie up years of character development from the comics into two hours, but for the most part Director Sam Raimi (who made the kick ass Evil Dead movies and the superhero type film, Dark Man) has managed to bring Peter Parker to life in a faithful way. But that is where the good points of this film almost end.
Peter Parker (Tobey Maguire) is the class nerd, someone nobody likes (except for outcast, Harry Osborn) and who gets picked on constantly. His transformation to Spider-Man occurs when he is bitten by a genetically altered spider, which gives him the ability to transform into a human spider. We witness him go through changes (with lots of puberty parallels) as he comes to grips with his new found powers. The true transformation is after the death of his Uncle Ben, something he is indirectly responsible for, which makes him realise “that with great power, comes great responsibility”. Along the way, he see a blossoming relationship with the girl of his dreams, Mary Jane Watson (Kirsten Dunst) as well as the introduction of the not so terrifying Green Goblin, whose origin we also discover as Norman Osborn (Willem Dafoe) descends into craziness. Of course Spider-Man saves the day and we see how Peter must cope with being the unappreciated hero.
The telling of Peter’s transformation is handled perfectly. Not only is it extremely faithful to the comic books, but it is also shown extremely well within the film. Tobey Maguire was perfectly cast as Peter and he plays the role to perfection, and shows all the sides of the character. Not only does he play the nerdy side extremely well, but the exuberance that the character shows when discovering his new abilities is also fantastic. We see an actor here who truly fits the part of the character and not some typical hunky guy who would have been totally unrealistic in this role (read: Freddie “I am a fag who only acts in gay teenage romance movies so little girls can dig on me” Prinze Jr, who actually campaigned for the role and, thank the holy lord, did not get it). Unfortunately, this is the only great character in the film.
A big disappointment in the film is the Mary Jane character. She just turns out to be the typical damsel in distress, when in fact she could (and should) have been so much more. The relationship between her and Peter is actually handled very well, it grows throughout the film and the outcome of her feelings for Peter are not contrived but quite real. One big complaint though, Mary Jane is a bit of a slut. Going after four different guys is a bit much. A huge disappointment though is the Green Goblin. At first we see the seeds of Osborn going totally insane, but as soon as the crappy Goblin costume comes on, he just becomes the typical over the top super villain. He would have been much better served as being a truly terrifying, evil character, but instead we can get an idiot who flies around and laughs like a total assface all the time. J Jonah Jameson, the editor of the Daily Bugle, who takes an immediate disliking to Spider-Man is played extremely over the top (by J K Simmons), is definitely a highlight.
Now come the criticisms of the film in terms of it’s shortcomings with bringing the comic book to life. Most won’t care about these as they are quite useless if you are not familiar with spider-Man. First off, although it makes sense (after you have accepted the fact that someone can get the powers of a spider), it totally blows that Peter has the ability to shoot webbing directly from his body and does not use the self made webbing from the comic books. I know this is a small complaint, but I don’t like it. It sucks. Also, Mary Jane coming from a broken home is not only different from the comic books but totally irrelevant to the story and character. What was the point, it was not elaborated on nor did it add more to the character. Mary Jane is supposed to be a feisty, independent chick yet in the film she is constantly in need of male companionship. The Goblin character and his suit just plain sucked. Finally, the word “sheesh” could have been used at least once!!
Overall, Spider-Man is a great, fun film but something about it just leaves me with an empty feeling. The strong point, and the thing that they needed to achieve the most, was the Peter Parker character. They really needed to make the film about him, not Spider-Man, and they succeeded. When you see Spidey slinging from the rooftops, you are thinking that that is Peter Parker, not some under developed character in tights.